ICANN once again rejected a .xxx domain for adult content by a 9 to 5 board member vote that reflected the board’s widely differing positions on the proposal.
There was no general consensus on the plan that had religious groups and even the adult content industry divided.
The Friday vote, held in Lisbon Portugal, was the third by ICANN on the measure and made no forward progress on resolving the issue.
“This decision was the result of very careful scrutiny and consideration of all the arguments. That consideration has led a majority of the board to believe that the proposal should be rejected.
- Dr. Vint Cerf, ICANN chairman”
The measure was favored by some in the adult content business but not all and by some family support organizations that felt a .xxx domain could help regulate the industry.
Others complained that an adult domain could appear to be an endorsement of the business.
Some ICANN directors worried that a separate domain for sex sites would require it to get involved in policing content.
ICM Registry which first proposed the domain seven years ago, railed against the decision and said it would likely file a lawsuit against ICANN, according to published reports.
Dr. Vint Cerf, who is an executive at Google, said differences of opinion over the proposed domain appear to be growing in the adult content community.
My concern here is that over time, the two years that we’ve considered this, there has been a growing disagreement within the adult content community as to the advisability of this proposal.
- Dr. Vint Cerf
Board member Rita Rodin summed up the feelings of some other board members when she said an .xxx domain could be an “enforcement headache” for ICANN. She added that the decision was a difficult one for the board.
To find out more, check out the transcript of the Board meeting.
August 20th, 2008
1 Comment at "ICANN Again Vetoes ..XXX Domain"
I don’t think that a .xxx domain would be an endorsement of pornography. Is there anyone out there who doesn’t realize that porn is freely available on the internet to anyone with half a desire to find it? We’re forcibly reminded of that every few days by another “Are your children safe?” kind of story on the news.
I’m undecided on the idea of it being a hassle to regulate, though. I mean, wouldn’t they just apply the usual ‘net laws (i.e., no child porn) to the domain and allow anyone who wanted a .xxx to have one? Who would sign up for a .xxx without being a pornographer, aside from a few random jackasses who would do it for the novelty of the thing.
Oh well, they’re ICANN and I’m not, I’m sure they have a better grasp of the relevant points of the debate.
Comment Now!